Specific Ancestral Lines of the Boaz, Paul, Welty & Fishel Families
  • Home
    • Ancestors of Basil Albert Welty
    • Ancestors of Mary Lou Disbrow
    • Ancestors of Joseph Henry Fishel
    • Ancestors of Mildred Leone Marrison
  • Welty and Disbrow Lines
    • Basil Albert Welty and Mary Lou Disbrow >
      • Basil Franklin Welty and Margaret Elizabeth Cook >
        • Ignatius N. Welty and Cordelia Frances Sims >
          • Francis M. Welty and Mary T. O'Daniell >
            • John Welty and Elizabeth McMahan
            • Ignatius ODaniel and Elizabeth
          • Francis Marion Sims and Sarah L. Curtis >
            • Christopher Sims and Sabrina Peale
            • Daniel Curtis and Mary
        • William J. Cook and Sena Mary J. Brotherton >
          • William Cook, Sr. and Orlena M. Hannah >
            • William James Hannah and Amanda Maria Kellums
          • Moses Brotherton and Mary Margaret Statler >
            • James Brotherton and Nancy Farner
            • Adam Jefferson Statler and Harriet Jaco >
              • Peter Statler and Peggy Masters
      • Merwin Cephas Disbrow and Dora Elizabeth Padgett >
        • Lavoisier Watson Disbrow and Cora Alice Easton >
          • Lodowick W. Disbrow and Sarah Jane Whitcomb >
            • Daniel W. Disbrow and Jane Leek
            • Albert Whitcomb and Lucy Bishop >
              • James Whitcomb and Lucy Kilburn >
                • Robert Whitcomb and Eunice Sheldon >
                  • James Whitcomb and Sarah Winslow >
                    • James Whitcomb and Mary Parker >
                      • Robert Whitcomb and Mary Cudworth >
                        • John Whetcomb and France Cogan >
                          • Henry Cogan and Joane Boridge
                        • General James Cudworth and Mary >
                          • Reverend Ralph Cudworth, D.D., M.A. and Mary Machell >
                            • Rauphe Cudworthe and Jane Ashton
                      • William Parker and Mary Turner >
                        • Humphrey Turner and Lydia Gaymer >
                          • Richard Gaymer, Jr. and Margaret Mason >
                            • Richard Gaymer, Sr. and Alice Dobbes
                    • Major Edward Winslow, Esquire and Sarah >
                      • Kenelm Winslow, Jr. and Mercy Worden >
                        • Kenelm Winslow and Ellenor Newton >
                          • Edward Winslow and Magdalene Ollyver >
                            • Kenelm Winslow
                        • Peter Worden II and Mary >
                          • Peter Worden (the elder) and Margaret Grice >
                            • Robert Worden and Isabel Worthington
                            • Thomas Grice and Alice
              • Amos B. Bishop and Rhoda Hildreth >
                • Daniel Bishop and Bettey Bowen >
                  • Uriel Bowen and Elizabeth Perry >
                    • Richard Bowen and Patience Peck >
                      • Richard Bowen and Esther Sutton >
                        • Richard Bowen
                      • Joseph Peck, Jr. and Hannah >
                        • Joseph Peck, Sr. and Rebecka Clark >
                          • Robert Peck and Hellen Babbs >
                            • Robert Pecke and Johan Waters
                            • Nicholas Babbs and Helen Parkhurst
                          • John Clark and Elizabeth
                • Abel Hildreth and Huldah Edwards >
                  • Sampson Hildreth and Lydia Parlin >
                    • Jonathan Hildreth and Hannah Spaulding >
                      • Ephraim Hildreth and Ann Moore >
                        • Richard Hildreth and Elizabeth
                        • John Moore and Ann Smith >
                          • John Moore and Ellesabeth
                          • John Smith
                    • John Parling and Mary Heald >
                      • John Parlen and Mary Heartwell >
                        • Nicholas Parlin and Sarah Hanmore
                        • Samuell Hartwell and Ruth Wheeler >
                          • William Hartwell and Jasan
                          • George Wheeler and Katherine Pin >
                            • Thomas Wheeler
                      • John Heald and Mary Chandler >
                        • John Heald and Sarah Dane >
                          • John Heald and Eunice Blackeburne
                          • Thomas Dane and Elizabeth
                        • Roger Chandler and Mary Simonds >
                          • William Simonds and Judith Phippin >
                            • William Phipping
                  • Samuel Edwards and Huldah Estabrook >
                    • Abraham Estabrook and Martha Brabrook
          • Sylvester G. Easton and Sarah M. Everett >
            • Daniel Easton and Lesbe Van Wey >
              • Josiah Easton
            • William Everett and Sarah
        • James Henry Padgett and Myrtle L. Hale >
          • Charles Morris Padgett, Jr. and Georgiaetta Elzea >
            • Charles Padgett and Mary E. Wilbur >
              • Robert Padgett and Susannah Shapley >
                • John Padgett and Hannah Wilson
                • Utter Shole Shapley and Sarah >
                  • Thomas Shapley and Johannah Utter >
                    • David Shapley, Jr. and Hepsibah French >
                      • David Shapley, Sr.
                      • John French and Phoebe Keyes >
                        • Ensign Thomas French and Mary Scudamore >
                          • Thomas French and Susan Riddlesdale >
                            • Jacob French and Susan Warren
                            • John Riddledale and Dorcas
                          • William Scudamore (III) and Margery Lechmere >
                            • William Scudamore (II) and Mary Burghill
                        • Robert Keyes and Sarah Swett >
                          • John Swett and Phebe Benton
                    • Samuel Utter and Johannah Preston >
                      • Jabez Utter and Mary >
                        • Nicholas Utter
                      • Samuel Preston, Jr. and Sarah Bridges >
                        • Samuel Preston, Sr. and Susannah Gutterson >
                          • Roger Preston and Martha
                          • William Gutterson and Elizabeth
                        • John Bridges and Sarah Howe >
                          • Edmond Bridges and Elizabeth
                          • James How and Elizabeth Dane >
                            • Robert Howe
                            • John Dane and Francis
            • Rufus Elzea and Catherine A. Depew
          • George W. Hale and Jane Elizabeth Dobbyn >
            • Levi Hale and Polly Coats >
              • Stephen Coats, Jr. and Polly Narramore
            • James Dobbyn and Margaret Ester Drake >
              • Henry Dobbyn and Elizabeth Bobier >
                • Gregory Bobier and Martha Willis
              • William Drake and Hannah Montross >
                • Peter Montross and Leah Mabie >
                  • Peter Montras and Emmetje Anderzon >
                    • Harmen Harmse and Margaret Montras >
                      • Jan Harremse and Aeltje Abrahams >
                        • Harmen Jansen and Margariet Meyring >
                          • Jan Meyer and Teuntie Straetmans
                        • Abraham Ryck and Grietje Hendricks >
                          • Hendrick Harmensen
                      • Pierre Montras and Marguerite David >
                        • Barthelemi Montarras and Marguerite Bodat
                        • Guillaume David and Marie Armand
                  • Simon Mabie >
                    • Caspar Meby and Lysbeth Schuurmans >
                      • Pieter Caspersen van Naarden and Aechte Jans van Norden
                      • Frederick Schuerman and Christina Jans >
                        • Jan Jansen Hagenaar
  • Fishel and Marrison Lines
    • Joseph Henry Fishel and Mildred Leone Marrison >
      • James Nicholas Fishel and Selina Eliza Hepworth >
        • Jacob Henry Fishel and Eliza Catherine Fleener >
          • Henry Fishel, Jr. and Teresa E. Hollanbuck >
            • Heinrich Fishel, Sr. >
              • Johann Adam Fishel and Ursula Catharina Thomas >
                • Johannes Fishell and Anna Maria Elisabetha Schmidt >
                  • Johann Jacob Schmidt
          • Aaron Fleener and Frances G. Waggoner >
            • Samuel Fleener and Mary Ann Watson >
              • Jacob Fleenor >
                • Johannes Flinner and Anna
            • Burgess Waggoner and Nancy Shipp >
              • Herbert Green Waggener and Nancy Willis >
                • James Waggener and Ann Jones >
                  • Herbert Waggener >
                    • John Waggoner and Rachell
                  • James Jones
                • William Willis
              • Richard Shipp and Mary C. Copeland >
                • Richard Shipp and Isabel Martin >
                  • Richard Shipp >
                    • Richard Shipp and Mary >
                      • Josias Shipp, Sr. and Elizabeth Brooks >
                        • Thomas Brooks and Susanna
                • James Copeland and Martha Johnson
        • William Bramwell Hepworth, Sr. and Ann Eliza Emery >
          • Samuel Clayton Hepworth and Martha Holliwood >
            • William Hepworth and Margaret Clayton
            • Job Hollywood
          • Edward Emery, Jr. and Elizabeth Ellen Holiday >
            • Edward Emery, Sr. and Julia Ann Freed >
              • Josiah Emery and Abigail Cutter >
                • William Emery and Mary Chase >
                  • Edward Emery and Sarah Sibley >
                    • Jonathan Emery and Mary Woodman >
                      • John Emery (II) and Mary Shatswell
                      • Edward Woodman, Jr. and Mary Goodrich >
                        • Edward Woodman, Sr. >
                          • Edward Woodman and Collett Mallett >
                            • Thomas Woodman
                        • William Goodrich and Margaret Butterfield
                    • Samuel Sibley and Sarah Wells >
                      • Richard Sibley and Hanna
                      • John Wells and Sarah Littlefield >
                        • Thomas Wells and Abigail Warner >
                          • William Warner
                        • Francis Littlefield and Rebecca >
                          • Edmund Littlefield and Annis Austin >
                            • Francis Littlefield and Mary
                            • Richard Asten
                  • Nathan Chase and Judith Sawyer >
                    • Thomas Chase and Rebecca Follansbee >
                      • Aquilla Chase and Ann Wheeler >
                        • John Wheeler and Agnes Yeoman >
                          • Dominick Wheeler and Mercye Jellye
                      • Thomas Follansbee, Sr. and Mary
                    • John Sawyer and Mary Browne >
                      • Samuel Sawyer and Mary Emery >
                        • William Sawyer and Ruth
                        • John Emery (III) and Mary
                      • Isaac Browne and Rebecca Bailey >
                        • Thomas Browne and Mary Healy
                        • John Bayly, Jr. and Eleanor Emery >
                          • John Bayly, Sr. and Anne Bayly
                          • John Emery (II) >
                            • John Emery (I)
            • Jesse Holiday and Abigail Osborn >
              • Robert Holiday and Edith Davis >
                • William Holaday and Jane Andrew >
                  • Henry Holaday and Mary Fayle
                  • Robert Andrew and Sarah
                • Jessee Davis and Elizabeth Reynolds >
                  • James Davis and Patience Miller >
                    • Robert Miller and Ruth Haines >
                      • Gayen Miller and Margret
                      • Joseph Haines and Dorothy
                  • David Reynolds and Mary Parker >
                    • William Reynolds and Mary Browne >
                      • Henry Reynolds and Prudence Clayton >
                        • William Reynolds and Margaret Exton >
                          • John Exton
                        • William Clayton and Prudence Lanckford >
                          • William Claiton and Jone Smith >
                            • William Claiton, Sr.
                      • William Browne and Kathrine Williams >
                        • Richard Browne
                    • Abraham Parker and Elinor Richardson >
                      • John Parker and Mary Doe
                      • Isaack Richardson and Katherine Gandy >
                        • Richard Gandy and Ellin
              • Abraham Osborn and Martha Hodson >
                • Abraham Osborn and Abigail Davies >
                  • William Ozbun and Rebecca Cox >
                    • Mathew Osborn II and Isabell Dobson >
                      • Mathew Osborn
                    • Richard Cox and Elizabeth Scarlett >
                      • Humphry Scarlett and Anne Richards >
                        • Joseph Richards and Jone
                  • Charles Davies and Hannah Matson >
                    • John Matson
                • Robert Hodson and Rachel Mills >
                  • George Hodgson and Mary
                  • Thomas Mills and Elizabeth Harrold >
                    • John Mills
                    • Richard Harrold and Mary Baels >
                      • John Beals and Mary Clayton
      • Emry Elmer Marrison and Hattie Alice Morse >
        • John Marrison and Esther Jane Pierce >
          • William Marrison and Mary Ann Gray >
            • Edward Marrison and Lucy Lee >
              • Thomas Marrison
              • Thomas Lee
          • James E. Pierce and Susan A. St. Johns >
            • Franklin Pierce and Rebeca
        • William F. Morse and Alice Lillian Blodgett >
          • Hiram B. Morse and Mary Syers
          • Alonzo Blodget and Sarah Ann Morgan >
            • Ziba Blodget and Dianna Burras
            • Zenas Morgan and Rebecca Williams
  • Preview the Book
  • References
    • References 15H through AX4
    • References B30 through BY1
    • References CA1 through CY1
    • References DA1 through DY2
    • References EA1 through EY1
    • References FA1 through FU3
    • References GA1 through GW1
    • References HA1 through HY1
    • References ID1 through IT1
    • References JA1 through KU1
    • References LA1 through LY1
    • References MA1 through MA25
    • References MA26
    • References MA27 through MA71
    • References MC1 through MI22
    • References MI23
    • References MI24 through MY2
    • References NA1 through NU3
    • References OB1 through OW2
    • References PA1 through QU3
    • References RA1 through RY6
    • References SA1 through SW2
    • References TA1 through TY1
    • References UK1 through US10
    • References US11
    • References US12 through UT1
    • References VA1 through VO3
    • References WA1 through WY3
    • References YA1 through ZO1
  • Contact the Author
​Their child:
 
Individuals in this page:
 
Their parents:
 
 
Aaron Fleener
{
Samuel Fleener
&
Mary Ann Watson
Eliza Catherine Fleener
{
&
 
 
 
 
Frances G. Waggoner
{
Burgess Waggoner
​&
Nancy Shipp

Aaron Fleener (Samuel, Mary Ann) was born on March 30, 1807 in Sullivan County, Tennessee, RE14, HA32. In the 1910 census, his daughter, Eliza, stated that her father was born in Virginia. He first married Mary Ann Weddle on October 8, 1829 in Monroe County, Indiana RE14, IN6, HA32. Mary Ann Weddle was born on February 3, 1808 HA32 and died sometime between 1845 and 1848 in Brown County, Indiana RE14, HA32.

With Mary Ann, he was the father of Samuel T., Mary Ellen, Lucinda, Sarah, James Addison, Jacob, John Martin Van Buren, Andrew Jackson, and Rosana Fleener. The 1850 census recorded nine of his children who were all born in Indiana; the youngest, Nancy J., was eleven months old and was his first daughter with Frances.

Samuel T. Fleener was born about 1831 UN10, HA32 in Indiana HA32 and he married Mary Hendrickson on November 3, 1850 in Monroe County, Indiana IN22, HA32. He resided in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana in June 1863 and was thirty-two years old as of July 1, 1863 US3. Mary Ellen Fleener was born about 1832 RE14 and may have been the Mary E. Fleenor who married Jeremiah Richardson on August 25, 1848 in Brown County, Indiana IN21. She allegedly died in 1875 RE14. Lucinda Fleener was born about 1834 UN10, HA32. She was probably the woman named Lucinda Hendrickson who in 1860 was twenty-six with three young children who resided with Aaron and Frances Fleener in Jackson, Brown County, Indiana UN11. Lucinda Hendrickson was buried in the same cemetery as Aaron Fleener, Mary Ann (Weddle) Fleener, and Frances G. (Waggoner) Fleener RE13.

Sarah (Fleener) Weddle was born on February 22, 1836 IN20, HA32 in Brown County, Indiana to Aaron Fleener and Mary “Weddel” IN20, and she married McCallen G. Weddel on December 23, 1852 in Brown County, Indiana IN21 (or McCallum Green Weddle on November 23, 1852 HA32). She died at the age of sixty-six on January 20, 1903 IN20, HA32 in Jackson, Brown County, Indiana from asthma and “Catorrhal [catarrhal] Pneumonia” IN20, which is bronchopneumonia. Her death certificate stated that her husband’s name was “M.G. Weddle” IN20.

James Addison Fleener was born on January 27, 1837 in Indiana to Aaron Fleener IN20, HA32, and he married Nancy McLary on May 5, 1859 in Brown County, Indiana IN21, HA32. He died at age seventy-six on March 6, 1913 IN20, HA32 in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana from cerebral softening, with cerebral apoplexy as a contributing factor to his death IN20. His death certificate stated that his wife’s name was Nancy IN20.

Jacob Fleener was born about 1840 UN10, HA32. Jacob married Elizabeth Richardson on February 12, 1863 HA32. He was probably the same Jacob N. Fleener who resided in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana in June 1863 and was thirty-one years old as of July 1, 1863, for this Jacob was listed with other Fleener men who were likely his brothers: Samuel T. and Andrew J. Fleener US3. John M.V.B. (John Martin Van Buren Fleener RE14, HA32) was born about 1842 UN10 or in 1841 HA32. John M.V. Fleener, the son of Aaron Fleener, was born on June 12, 1841 in Indiana IN20. He and Dorcas Taylor were married on February 24, 1863 IN21, HA32 by Daniel D. Griffin, Minister of the Gospel in Brown County, Indiana IN21. He died of paralysis at the age of seventy-seven on January 3, 1919 in Brooklyn, Morgan County, Indiana IN20. According to Frank Fleener of Martinsville, who was the son of John Martin Van Buren Fleener, his mother died on February 26, 1918 at the age of seventy-six HA32.

Andrew J. (Andrew Jackson Fleener RE14, HA32) was born about 1844 UN10, HA32. Andrew J. Fleener resided in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana in June 1863 and was twenty years old as of July 1, 1863 US3. Andrew J. Fleener was born on April 10, 1843 in Brown County, Indiana to “Aron Fleener” who was born in Virginia and a mother whose maiden name was “Weddle” IN20. Andrew J. Fleener married Eliza Jane Brock on December 25, 1864 IN6, HA32. Andrew died at age sixty-one from a gunshot wound to the head on November 15, 1904 in Washington Township, Brown County, Indiana IN20. At the time of his death, his wife was Eliza J. Fleener IN20.

Rosannah/Rosana Fleener was born about 1845 UN10, UN11, HA32 in Brown County Indiana RE14. Rosana (Fleener) McClung was born on April 13, 1845 in Indiana to “Aron” Fleener and “Joana Wedel” IN20. She was said to have married William Gilmore on November 4, 1866 in Monroe County, Indiana RE14. She may have been thirty-four-year-old Rosa Gilmore who was born in Indiana and was enumerated in the 1880 US Census in Cawker, Mitchell County, Kansas with her husband, William Gilmore and their four daughters and one son: Olive, who was twelve, Melissa, eleven, Lida, six, Evaline, four, and Leslie, who was nine months old UN13. Her four daughters were born in Indiana, but Leslie was born in Kansas UN13. Five years later the 1885 Kansas State Census recorded five members of the Gilmore family who resided in Downs, Osborne County, Kansas, which is approximately six miles west of Cawker: R.A. Gilmore, a forty-year-old woman, Jennie, who was sixteen, Lida, eleven, Eva, who was eight, and John Gilmore, who was five. The death record for John L. Gilmore stated that he was born on August 29, 1879 to William Gilmore and Roseann Fleaner IL2. Rosanna Gilmore and Charles McClung were married by James R. Moody, Minister of the Gospel on March 31, 1896 in Morgan County, Indiana IN21. At the time of her death on June 25, 1914, she was married to Charles McClung IN20. Rosana died at age of sixty-nine in Wayne Township, Owen County, Indiana from cancer of the stomach and liver IN20.

Aaron Fleener and Michael Fleener were among the twelve “hands” who lived near or along the “Jackson’s Licks & Martinsville road” who were to report to the newly appointed superintendent, William Davidson, in 1836 GO10. This group of men appear to have been tasked with extending the road northward to Bear Creek GO10. According to the Johnson County, Indiana Record Book AA, page 61 and Probate Order Book B, page 11, Aaron Fleenor was appointed the administrator of the estate of George B. Campbell on October 26, 1836, and Samuel Fleenor and Thomas Walker were named as his securities HO25. Aaron Fleener, Jacob Fleener, Milton Fleener, Frederick Fleener, Jackson Fleener, and Abraham Fleener were mentioned in a list of men who paid a poll tax in 1848 GO10.

Aaron Fleener married Frances G. Waggoner on July 3, 1848 in Johnson County, Indiana IN22, TR6, RI12, RE14, SH6. He purchased three parcels of land of forty acres apiece in Brown County, Indiana on October 21, 1834, September 16, 1835, and May 10, 1848 GE4. On the same day, May 10, a man whose name was typed in the General Land Office Records as “Aaron Flunor”, was certainly Aaron Fleener, as not only was his handwritten surname on the actual record fairly clear as “Fleenor”, but the two parcels of forty acres, both purchased on May 10, were adjacent to each other GE4. He bought two separate parcels of forty acres apiece in Brown County on November 1, 1849, and then thirty-two acres of land in Monroe County, Indiana on April 15, 1853 GE4. Monroe County is adjacent to Jackson Township, Brown County. By 1849, Aaron owned one quarter of the land in Section 36 of Brown County BO15, but a great deal of these parcels of land are now underwater, as Bean Blossom Creek, which likely provided his source of water for irrigation purposes, was dammed in the 1950s to create Lake Lemon SC3.

Aaron Fleener, father of Eliza Catherine, was probably not the Aaron Fleener who served as a private in Company G of the 27th Indiana Infantry in the Civil War CI3. This particular Aaron Fleener, of Morgan County, Indiana, enlisted on September 12, 1861 and was discharged on September 1, 1864 at Indianapolis AM3. Our Aaron Fleener was not associated with Morgan County, and not only would he have been an advanced age at the time of the Civil War, but his very death was said to have occurred before the date of discharge.

Aaron may have died in January 1863 in Brown County, Indiana, and was said to have been buried on his farm with an unmarked gravestone RE14. The family cemetery, according to Kenneth and Helen Reeve, is situated near Possom Trot Road, almost half of a mile north of North Shore Drive, and 400 feet east of the road, in the southwest quarter of the southeast quarter of Section 25, in Jackson Township RE14, RE13. His estate inventory was dated March 30, 1863 RE14, but his probate documents may have been burned in a courthouse fire in November 1873 RE12. Francis G. Fleener became the guardian for Aaron’s minor heirs, but in October 1866, their guardianship was transferred to Samuel T. Fleener RE12.

·         1840 US Census: lived in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana.

·         1850 US Census: lived in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana.

·         1860 US Census: lived in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana.

Frances G. Waggoner (Burgess, Nancy) was born on October 15, 1826 in Franklin, Indiana to Burgess and Nancy (Shipp) Waggoner RE14, SH6, TR6. She was born in 1826 in Indiana UN10, UN11 or about 1827 in Indiana UN13. She was the mother of Nancy Jane, Eliza Catherine, Simon Peter Calvin, Martha Elizabeth, Amanda C., and Samantha E. Fleener.

Nancy J. (Nancy Jane RE14) was born about 1848 UN11 or 1849 UN10, HA32 in Indiana UN10, UN11. Nancy Fleener was recorded in at least four instances in Marriage Record 2 Dec 1858 – Sep 1874 for Brown County, Indiana, but because these marriage records did not state the names of the parents of the bride or groom, it is not possible to determine if any of these brides were the daughter of Aaron and Frances Fleener IN21. All of these weddings occurred in 1866. Nancy Fleener and W.W. Norman married on February 25, 1866, Nancy J. Fleener married James A. Weddle on May 27, 1866, Nancy J. Fleener married Temple S. Davis on September 6, 1866, and Nancy Jane Fleener married William P. Spriggs on December 20, 1866 IN21. Further, in nearby Washington County, Indiana there were at least three brides who may have been the daughter of Aaron and Frances, but these marriage records also did not include the parents’ names: Nancy Fleener married Peter Huckleberry on January 28, 1869, Nancy Fleenor married Francis M. Smith on February 12, 1869, and Nancy Fleenor and Joseph C. Preston applied for a marriage license on September 22, 1866 IN21.

She was not the Nancy Fleener who married W.W. Norman, because this Nancy’s Morgan County, Indiana death certificate dated June 3, 1925 stated that she was the wife of Wallace Norman, but her parents were Fred Fleener and Anglline Kelly. She was not the Nancy Jane Fleener who married William P. Spriggs, for this Nancy’s Monroe County, Indiana death certificate dated August 28, 1918 stated that she was the wife of William P. Spriggs, but her parents were Abraham Fleener and Sarah Jane Alexander. She was not the Nancy J. Fleener who married Temple S. Davis, because Nancy Jane Davis’ Monroe County, Indiana death certificate dated November 3, 1918 stated that she was the wife of Temple Stuart Davis and the daughter of Jack Fleener and Polley Hensley. She was probably not the Nancy Fleener who married Peter Huckleberry, because this Nancy’s Washington County, Indiana death certificate dated December 23, 1920 stated that she was a widow whose parents were George W. Fleener and Carsline (or Caroline) Western.

Eliza Catherine Fleener was born in February 1851 in Indiana UN14. Simon P.C. (Simon Peter Calvin RE14) was born about 1852 UN11. The White County, Indiana death certificate for “Simmon Calvon” Fleener stated that he was born on December 4, 1852 in Brown County, Indiana to a father whose surname was Fleener and a mother named Frances IN20. Simon C. Fleener married Fanny M. Sedam or Fanny Mae Sedam in Johnson County, Indiana on August 6, 1874 RI13, RE14. Fannie Marie (Seadam) Fleener was married to Simon Fleener at the time of her death on October 20, 1911 IN20. Simon died as a widower at age fifty-nine on March 2, 1912 in Honey Creek Township, White County, Indiana from apoplexy with and heart disease as a contributing factor IN20. Martha (Martha Elizabeth RE14) was born about 1857 UN11. She may have been the Martha E. Fleener who married James McCoy on May 1, 1889 in Brown County, Indiana RE29. Amanda C. Fleener was born in 1859 UN11. Amanda Fleener of Hume, Edgar County, Illinois, the daughter of Aaron Fleener and Franchs… Wagnor, age twenty, married Preston Cox in Hume, Edgar County, Illinois on or after December 28, 1880, but before January 7, 1881 ED7. Amanda stated that she was born in Brown County, Indiana ED7. Samantha E. (Fleener) Richards, the daughter of Aaron Fleener and Francis Wagoner, was born on November 8, 1862 in Indiana IL2; her marriage record indicated that she was born in Brown County, Indiana ED7. Samantha, the eighteen-year-old daughter of Aron Fleener and Francis Wagner, and William A. Richard, were married on December 17, 1879 in Hume, Edgar County, Illinois by J.H. Williams ED7. She died at age fifty-seven on July 29, 1920 in Casey, Clark County, Illinois IL2.

After the death of Aaron, Frances remarried three times. The marriage of William Purdy and Frances G. “Fleenor” (a different record stated “F G Fleener” ED7) took place on June 6, 1870 in Edgar County, Illinois ED7, IL1, IL5. G.W. Rives, Justice of the Peace, certified the marriage ED7. Two years later, Frances G. Purdy and Norman Reed were married by G.W. Burns, Justice of the Peace, on November 26, 1872 in Morgan County, Indiana IN21. Norman Reed probably died sometime between 1872 and 1880, because in 1880, Frances was enumerated as “Fleener, Francis” with her daughters, Martha, born about 1858, and Amanda, born about 1860. This census enumerator recorded that the birth location of the father of Martha and Amanda was Virginia. Her fourth marriage, to Samuel Richard (or Richards), a seventy-one-year-old farmer from Ohio, occurred on July 24, 1890 in Brown County, Indiana IN7. The Record of Returns of Marriages for Brown County recorded their correct marriage date of July 24, 1890, which was after their license was issued on July 19, but Volume 4 of the marriages of Brown County stated that they were married on July 4, before their license was issued to them IN7. The Record of Returns of Marriages described Frances as “Frances G. Reed”, whose maiden name was Wagoner, the daughter of “Bergus Wagner”, who was then sixty-four years old IN7. This record stated that she had been married four times, but it may have included the most recent marriage in this count IN7. Frances was said to have been buried in the same family cemetery as Aaron and Mary Ann RE14, RE13. A representative from the Brown County Department of Health stated that a death record for Frances (Waggoner) Richards was not filed in that county.

·         1850 US Census: lived in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana.

·         1860 US Census: lived in Jackson Township, Brown County, Indiana.

·         1880 US Census: lived in Hume Village, Young America Township, Edgar County, Illinois.

© 2025 Adrienne Boaz